Undecided voters like Joan could swing this election, but may leave America more divided

Blue tarpaulin sheets covering the roofs of thousands of homes flap in the warm Louisiana wind as workmen clear away broken tiles and window frames.

Outside the houses, huge piles of sodden carpets, broken electrical appliances, sofas, chairs and beds tumble onto the streets already clogged by fallen telegraph poles and trees.

It’s over two months since Hurricane Laura ripped through the town of Lake Charles, bringing death, destruction and misery that continues today.

Image:Lake Charles has been devastated not once, but twice by hurricanes this season

This really has not been a good year for the residents of this town known for its oil and casinos.

It has been flattened not once but twice by severe hurricanes this season – and the season is not over yet.

In the midst of all this, the town was engulfed by COVID-19– infecting people and destroying much of the local economy.

They feel forgotten.

More from Us Election 2020

  • US Election 2020: Georgia’s black voters fired up amid claims of intimidation and suppression

  • US Election 2020: Why Martin Luther King III fears a disputed election result and talk of civil war

  • America Decides: How does the US election work and which way will it swing?

  • Trump calls out Biden for confusing him with George W Bush – ‘couldn’t remember my name’

  • US Election 2020: Surge of early voting hits record levels ahead of US election

  • US Election 2020: Trump supporters show Biden that winning Pennsylvania won’t be as easy as the polls say

Outside the motorhome she now lives in, while she waits for her home to be rebuilt, Joan Arbie shows me her outdoor kitchen, while surveying the destruction that’s affected the homes of all her neighbours.

“We are grateful for what we have left,” she tells me.

Image:Joan Arbie has doubts about both candidates

What has happened to Joan is typical of many people in Lake Charles.

Her partner, Bridget, contracted COVID-19, their home was destroyed in the hurricanes, she has lost her job and is waiting for the insurance to come through so that she isn’t flat broke and can afford the house rebuild.

The thing is Joan is very much not typical to most in this town and indeed across the US, in one crucial and interesting way.

She is an undecided voter.

If the 2020 US presidential election has one overriding characteristic, it’s that almost everyone has already decided who they will vote for.

Donald Trump has ensured that there is barely a person in the land who does not either love him or hate him. There doesn’t seem to be much middle ground. Which brings us back to undecided Joan.

What struck me is that Joan’s indecision really weighs upon her mind.

She sees the election as vitally important, a defining moment even, in the country’s political and social evolution.

“I’m kind of on the fence between being conservative and liberal, but I think some of the things that are being said on the liberal side are more disturbing to me than on the conservative side, so that’s kind of where I am having to make a decision as to who I am going to vote for, and it’s a very difficult decision, and like I said it’s kind of a scary one as well.”

The swing states where the race to the White House will be won and lost

The swing states where the race to the White House will be won and lost

:: Subscribe to the Daily podcast on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Spotify, Spreaker

The truth is, Joan, like thousands if not millions of Americans, isn’t too keen on either of the candidates running for the highest office.

A 56-year-old former university athletics coach, with two teenage daughters, lots of friends in the UK and a love of driving holidays, is naturally of a liberal disposition.

But clearly the Democrats in this election appear to be spooking her more than Trump’s often divisive actions and words.

“Well I kind of have a feeling who I am going to vote for at this point, but still it just tears at you, you know, what side you’re going to go to, because it’s just so much uncertainty. I mean someone who hasn’t been in office they can tell you they’re going to give you the moon but are they capable of that?”

She then pauses to think. Her dilemma is that she’s not sure about Trump either.

“I think with Donald Trump – his debates didn’t go so well he seemed a little you know, a little too aggressive in my opinion in those debates… it’s been a very difficult decision and it’s actually been really stressful.”

Image:Hurricane season is still not over as the election looms

We join Joan on the final day of early voting in Lake Charles as she drives downtown to vote, still undecided.

Before she gets in the queue I ask her what, for her, is the one crucial issue in this election that she wants to see followed.

“Freedom, freedom, and what happens in the future for my children, that’s the defining issue for me.”

Lake Charles, like cities across the country, have seen record numbers of people turning out to vote before election day.

An election official here tells me that 40% of eligible voters had already done so. She predicted that after election day more than 80% will have voted.

That is astounding.

What it actually means for the two candidates is being discussed by observers and TV commentators here on an almost continuous basis.

Whatever the polls say, in truth, nobody really knows what is going to happen.

But people like Joan could be the ones who swing this one way or the other.

Joan with other early voters in Lake Charles, Louisiana
Image:Joan with other early voters in Lake Charles, Louisiana

After an hour or so in line this clearly jubilant, now decided, voter emerged punching the air.

“I have been quite nervous, a little scared about it, and I feel a lot better now I am done, now I have cast my vote, and know that I’ve been heard. My one vote may not make a huge difference, but it may make some difference.”

I ask her if she’d tell us who she voted for.

“No, I’m not telling you who I voted for, it may ruin some friendships, so I can’t tell you.”

Her fear of upsetting close family and friends is reflected across the US, a country now arguably more divided than ever before.

The key question is this – will the final result unite them or make things even worse?

Mark Gibson

Graduates in Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois 1990. Move to Los Angeles California in 2004. Specialized in Internet journalism.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *