Are elderly voters deserting Donald Trump?

Elderly voters helped put Donald Trump in office. They could also boot him out.

The polls tell a worrying story for the president.

In national and key battleground states, the turnaround from four years ago among voters 65 and over is pretty stark.

Mr Trump captured the senior vote by almost ten points, according to both the 2016 election day exit polls and the Pew Research Center analysis of the vote.

But a Wall Street Journal/NBC News national poll shows Joe Biden winning this group of voters by more than 20 points.

The margins in reality may be far thinner, but it’s a massively important voter block both men need to get on side.

Why do seniors matter?

More from Florida

  • US Election 2020: Trump flies in to woo Florida – but the grey vote might be turning against him

  • Navy Seals investigate video of ‘dog attack’ on man in Colin Kaepernick shirt

  • Coronavirus: Florida closes test centres as tropical storm Isaias nears – a day after record number of deaths

  • Party-going Floridians seem undeterred despite continued surge in coronavirus cases

  • Coronavirus: Florida man ‘bought Lamborghini after claiming nearly $4m in COVID-19 relief loans’

  • Florida TV reporter alerted to cancer after viewer spots lump on her neck

Ginni Mantel is convinced Trump will win again in Florida and the US
Image:Ginni Mantel is convinced Trump will win again in Florida and the US

Pew estimates seniors will account for almost a quarter of the electorate.

In 2016, if Hillary Clinton had divided the elderly vote, she could have carried the all-important states of Pennsylvania, Michigan and Florida so key to Mr Trump’s success.

Why the turnaround?

Political strategists suggest older voters are unhappy with the way the president has handled the pandemic, which disproportionately affects older voters.

Those voters 65 years and older represent 16% of the population, but account for 80% of the more than 210,000 deaths from COVID-19 in America.

Is it really that simple?

Probably not. This election is a referendum on Donald Trump and some seniors cite concerns about his character and ability to govern with civility.

Are there worrying signs for Mr Trump?

Senior voters were key to Donald Trump's election success, particularly in Florida
Image:Senior voters were key to Donald Trump’s election success, particularly in Florida

There are some unexpected shifts visible in a corner of Florida that’s usually a reliably Republican stronghold.

The Villages, billed as “America’s friendliest hometown”, has been experiencing some political division recently.

In the country’s oldest retirement community, residents drive around on golf carts. Spotting one with a Trump sign is no surprise.

But a new parade of Biden supporters has been driving around under the banner of “Ridin with Biden”.

Efrain believes older voters have stopped trusting Donald Trump
Image:Efrain believes older voters have stopped trusting Donald Trump

Local resident Efrain, who has been driving around in a cart with colourful Biden posters, says the president’s response to the pandemic will be a big factor in elderly peoples’ choices.

But he also believes older people have stopped trusting the president. Efrain also has two veteran sons and says he was incensed by reports Mr Trump called Americans who died in war, “suckers” and “losers”.

He said: “I don’t trust him. He’s a bigot and a bully and I don’t like bullies.”

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

How to win a US election

How much does he think the pandemic will play a part?

“Big,” he replies. “He did not react well.”

Ginni Mantel is convinced Trump will win again in Florida and the US
Image:Ginni Mantel is convinced Trump will win again in Florida and the US

Ginni Mantel feels very differently. She’s convinced the president will carry this area and the country.

She said: “This is Trump territory… we have 600-700 carts for Trump and then two weeks later, Biden turns up and they’re doing Ridin with Biden because they can’t do the Trump train.”

Hans Mantel says the divisive nature of US politics is forcing people apart
Image:Hans Mantel says the divisive nature of US politics is forcing people apart

Her husband, Hans, has a gloomy assessment of the political landscape.

“I think the animosity between the left and right has gone way beyond limits. I think there’s no way we can ever talk to each other any more. The idea of sitting down and having a conversation is no longer here,” he says.

Image:Opinion is divided in Florida – many think Trump will win the state, but perhaps not the White House

Down the road in a square where a group of 10 women are working out, another revealing if very crude perspective is raised.

I ask for a show of hands to indicate their 2020 choices. six say they will vote for Joe Biden, four for President Trump.

The majority of people we spoke to though, thought Mr Trump would ultimately win locally in an area where people favour fiscal conservatism and believe he is the better caretaker for the economy.

But a surprising amount also believed there was a potential for him to lose the national election.

The president will have to hope the silent vote, those unwilling to pledge allegiance to him in public, will once again roar like a lion.

We know elderly voters can be relied upon to take their views to the ballot box. This year is unlikely to be any different.

Mark Gibson

Graduates in Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois 1990. Move to Los Angeles California in 2004. Specialized in Internet journalism.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *